Tonight I saw Pirates of the Caribbean 2: Dead Man's Chest. Now, before I say anything about it, permit me one small digression...
In my experience, part two of any trilogy is almost always the weakest link. It has no beginning and no end. You can't even judge part two fairly until you see how it relates to part three. It's the cinematic Jan Brady.
Two trilogies come to mind when I think of really bad middle movies: The Matrix and Star Wars Episodes I-III.
"The Matrix" was an amazing cinematic achievement. All of the right characters and effects came together in the right story to make pure movie magic. It blew me away. It blew everyone away. Then "The Matrix: Reloaded" came out. I tried not to set my expectations too high... but it wasn't even in the same ballpark as the original "Matrix". I had hoped that by some miracle, "The Matrix: Revolutions" would right all of the wrong in "Reloaded"... and it didn't. The magic was gone.
No movie in my lifetime has been as highly anticipated as "Star Wars Episode I". It was doomed to failure for that reason alone. For all that it lacked, Darth Maul was pretty cool, the lightsaber fights were pretty cool, and the die-hard fans were willing to put up with a lot in that first movie...I mean, hell, it's
Star Wars! When Episode II came around, my expectations were slightly higher. I was hoping for a darker, more dramatic story more in line with "The Empire Strikes Back". Ugh. I can't even think about that movie without cringing. After that, I was honestly scared to see Episode III. I didn't want Lucas to mess up Darth Vader. BUT (miraculously) it didn't suck. In fact, Episode III was pretty damn good. Perhaps under different directing with a better script, it could have been "great". The moral of this story is even though part one was "ify" and part two was terrible, I walked away from that trilogy with a smile on my face.
Bringing me back to "Dead Man's Chest". I wanted to like it. I really, really wanted to like it. It was one of those terrible middle movies. Possibly one of the worst I have ever seen, purely because of poor storytelling. The acting and visual effects are spot-on. It's just missing a plot... character development... a purpose... AN ENDING! I drove home scratching my head. This may be the very first sequel I've ever seen where NOTHING was resolved in any way, shape or form. I like a good "cliffhanger" ending. This movie doesn't end, it simply stops.
Beyond the complete lack of a substantial story, there were so many little, obvious issues, I honestly can't see how part three can explain them all away. For instance, the monkey is still undead. Why is the monkey still undead? The curse was lifted- the first movie made it quite clear that EVERYONE'S blood was necessary to lift the curse (hence the importance of Will). Grrr... the monkey shouldn't be undead. :)
I really, really, really, really, really wanted this movie to be good. I didn't expect it to be as good as the original, but I still wanted it to have some of the same charm. If you go to see it, go to see Johnny and Orlando run around with swords while looking manly. It's a three hour preview for Pirates of the Caribbean 3.
With any luck, in that installment, we'll get swashbuckling over an erupting volcano instead of thousands of identical Jack Sparrows.